10 sensational old-fashioned savory mushroom recipes (1912)

10 sensational old-fashioned savory mushroom recipes (1912)

Note: This article may feature affiliate links, and purchases made may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Find out more here.


Tips for choosing mushrooms for savory mushroom recipes

The French cooks employ the mushroom quite generally in their work, using them often to replace meats, as for breakfast, luncheon, or supper, or as an adjunct, or merely to flavor, as in soup and sauces. 

Mushroom stems are not so tender and delicious as the tops, and should be chopped rather fine or sliced thin if they are cooked with the tops, or reserve the stems for flavoring soups or sauce.

While the French are the most reliable authorities for ways of serving, they can be of little service in teaching us how to distinguish the poisonous from the edible — or in the general classification — how to tell a mushroom from a toadstool.

The fact is that a mushroom is a fungus plant. and a toadstool is likewise a fungus plant. The mark of distinction is hard to define, so that a rule would hold good in every section of our country.

Do not buy fresh mushrooms of anyone who is not thoroughly versed in mushroom lore and understands the marked points of difference between the edible and poisonous varieties. The only reliable way to distinguish the edible from the poisonous is to be well versed in their chief points of difference, such as general appearance and habitat. And care should be observed in gathering only the fresh, tender growth.

10 sensational old-fashioned savory mushroom recipes (1912)

10 savory mushroom recipes

1. Baked mushrooms

Hold the mushrooms by the stem and dip into boiling hot water a moment to loosen the skins, then peel and cut off the stems. Boil the parings and stems and strain. Add this water to the mushrooms (chopped fine); add parsley and stew about 40 minutes.

Beat six eggs and add them to the mushrooms and then pour the mixture into a buttered pan or cups and bake in a quick oven. Serve with a cream sauce.

2. Broiled mushrooms

Wash and wipe them well and sprinkle with salt and pepper, removing the stems. Lay in a fine wire broiler and broil over a clear fire until they are tender and juicy-looking. Then lay on rounds of bread toasted on one side only.

Melt two pounds of butter and saute in it one cup chopped mushrooms, using the stems in this way. Season to taste with salt and pepper and add one-quarter cup heavy cream. Reheat and pour over the mushrooms and toast.

MORE: 7 magnificent mushroom appetizer recipes (’60s & ’70s)

3. Mushrooms cooked under a glass bell

Individual dishes can be used for this recipe, or one large dish. Cut rounds of bread the size of the mushrooms and toast nicely. Cover the bottom of the dish with these and place three or four washed and stemmed mushroom caps on each slice of toast, heaping them up in the center.

Baste with melted butter, dredge with salt and pepper and pour over them a small quantity of good, sweet cream — about six or eight tablespoons. Cover with the bell-shaped glass and stand in the oven for about 20 minutes to bake. Send to the table without uncovering, as thus you preserve the rich, fine flavor of the mushrooms.

4. Stuffed mushrooms recipe

Wash a dozen large, fresh mushrooms and break off the stems. Chop these fine. Peel the caps of the mushrooms.

Melt three tablespoons of butter in a porcelain-lined or earthen saute pan; add a level tablespoon of finely-minced shallot and the minced stems and stew gently for 10 minutes. Then add one and a half tablespoons flour, a grating of nutmeg, and veal or chicken stock to moisten. (A little cream will do if you have no stock.) Season with salt and pepper and a teaspoon of minced parsley.

Let the mixture cool, then stuff the caps with it, heaping up and well-rounding them. Cover with fine buttered breadcrumbs and bake in a hot oven for 15 minutes. Add parsley, if desired. Serve at once.

5. Mushrooms and spaghetti

Boil a half a pound of spaghetti in plenty of water (salted) until tender.

Put one pint of water in a saucepan with juice of a half lemon, a teaspoon salt, and half as much pepper. When it boils, add a quart of mushrooms and cook five minutes. Beat three eggs and stir them in; then remove at once from the fire.

Drain the spaghetti and put a layer in the bottom of a baking dish, then a layer of the mushrooms and fill the dish up in this way, leaving mushrooms on top. Place in a hot oven to bake for five minutes.

Savory mushroom recipes

6. Mushrooms with marrow

This dish is a favorite in some restaurants. Have the meat dealer split a shinbone and remove the marrow and cut this into inch thick slices. Then boil it for one and a half minutes in a quart of salted water, using a teaspoon of salt.

Into a frying pan, put a tablespoon of butter and let get hot; then add five tablespoons of chopped mushrooms and toss for five minutes. Sprinkle with a little salt and pepper. Drain the marrow, squeeze over it 10 drops of lemon juice and then mix with it the mushrooms. Spread on hot slices of crisp toast and serve at once.

7. Mushroom omelet recipe

Cook a dozen small, evenly-sized mushrooms in saucepan with a half ounce of butter and a half saltspoon of salt sprinkled over them. Make a plain French omelet, and as it cooks, at the edges place the mushrooms over one half of it, fold over the other half and slip from the pan into a hot dish and serve at once.

8. Mushrooms and lamb’s kidney

Slice one lamb’s kidney and saute in melted butter. Skim out of the butter and saute a dozen large mushrooms in the same butter, having washed and sliced them.

Melt two tablespoons butter, add two tablespoons flour, one and a half cups tomato, a few drops of onion juice, one and a half teaspoons Worcestershire sauce, a half teaspoon salt and a dash of pepper. Cook 10 minutes; add mushrooms and kidney and cook gently until the kidney is tender.

Serve in the center of a hot platter with a border of plain boiled rice or spaghetti and a cream sauce.

20 ways to serve potatoes (1912)

9. Mushrooms and oysters

Select large tender mushrooms. Wash well, remove stems and peel. Saute the caps in butter, using an enameled pan or earthen pie plate. Then arrange in a shallow baking dish with the hollow side up.

Place in each a fine, fat oyster, dust with salt and cayenne and lay a small slice of butter on each and cook in the hot oven until the oysters plump up and the gills begin to curl. Serve with a spoon of sauce, bechamel or brown butter sauce poured over each.

10. Savory mushroom recipes: Mushroom patties

Make a good forcemeat of chicken or cold roast beef, and fill prepared mushroom caps that are all of the same size. First wash, peel and stem then, chopping the stem and mixing with the saute the caps in butter.

Fill with the forcemeat and put together to form a ball. Cover with a thick cream sauce, then with bread crumbs dipped into beaten eggs and again cover with crumbs. Lay in a fine wire basket and fry in deep hot fat until nicely brown. Serve with sauce allemanda.

PS: If you liked this article, please share it! You can also get our free newsletter, follow us on Facebook & Pinterest. Thanks for visiting and for supporting a small business! 🤩 


You might also like...

The fun never ends:

Comments on this story

Leave a comment here!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.