San Francisco has turned into a skyscraper city: City of yesterday lost in the crush (1973)
By Earl Caldwell, Beckley Post-Herald (Beckley, West Virginia) July 8, 1973
SAN FRANCISCO: It is not the same here. The city has changed. On warm afternoons now, a thin line of ugly smog almost always hangs over the bay.
Downtown, jackhammers chop the last holes for a subway system soon to come. And up in North Beach, where topless entertainment was first introduced to the nation, a serious move is underway to put an end to the shows where entertainers now work in the nude.
The smog has brought concern. Uncertainty surrounds the subway. And as for the nude shows, there are different opinions. But of all the change that has come, what worries San Franciscans most nowadays is the sudden realization that this has become a high-rise city.
Many huge new buildings have risen here, shaping a skyline that local columnist Herb Caen recently said was “almost indistinguishable from Pittsburgh’s, Houston’s or Atlanta’s.”
Caen, who has written his column from San Francisco since 1936, mentions that Atlanta refers to itself proudly as the San Francisco of tomorrow. But he adds that it may already be the San Francisco of today if tall buildings are the yardstick.
“It’s the San Francisco of yesterday that has been last in the crush,” he wrote. “Something charming, perishable and, it turns out, unique is being trampled to death by those to whom less is more and ugly is beautiful.”
San Francisco in the 1970s: The Transamerica Pyramid photo
From the rim of the financial district downtown, the pyramid building built by Transamerica Corp. has emerged as the symbol of high-rise San Francisco. It is a giant building, the tallest in the city, and unlike any other.
Although it has but 48 floors of usable office space, a 212-foot spire perched atop the pyramid enables it to stretch above even the 42-story building that the Bank of America constructed as its world headquarters.
Just as the pyramid has become the city’s tallest building, rising 853 feet, it has also become the most controversial. Even while it was being constructed there were suggestions that it be torn down.
Now that it has been completed, the controversy has grown. Its location has been criticized. The spire that sits atop the building has been called an ego trip. Some have even called the pyramid a “Los Angeles-type building,” a stinging criticism here.
But oddly, even those who dislike the building the most concede that at night as it sits there alongside its formidable neighbors, together they make a breathtaking sight. Others argue that night lights mean little. As proof, they point to New York. “From a distance, Manhattan looks good at night, too,” they say.
The move towards high-rise building began there near the end of the ’50s. Then, through the ’60s San Francisco experienced its biggest development boom since the earthquake in 1906.
In the last decade alone, some 40 new skyscrapers were built, finally leading to a rebellion in 1971 when voters went to the polls and attempted to force a seven-story height limit on builders. That initiative was defeated, but it did result in height limits being established in most neighborhoods.
Downtown, however, skyscrapers continue to rise. Just last month, plans were proposed to rebuild the city’s transit terminal, replacing the existing facility with a complex of three high-rise buildings. And while it is not entirely high-rise, there are also plans underway to develop a huge $385 million convention center complex south of Market Street, just off the downtown district.
But the fear of high-rise living that is growing here threatens both of those projects and perhaps many others. Two years ago, the highs rise issue was taken to the ballot by a citizens groups put together largely by Alvin Duskin, the former dress manufacturer and urban conservationist.
Now, Duskin is heading an-other group that is preparing an initiative to put the convention center on the ballot this November. If it passes, it would forbid the city from spending any money on the project.
Duskin said that a prime reason San Francisco has a chance to avoid total high-rise development is because “here people are still in the city, trying to slug it out. That makes a difference.”
In a recent edition of the San Francisco Chronicle, an article appeared that shocked many citizens. It was entitled “The End of the California Dream.” It told of the disenchantment with Los Angeles and how residents are now leaving that city at the rate of 300 a day.
But the piece ended with lengthy interviews of San Franciscans who dislike the changing city and plan to move elsewhere. In each, case, the moving couples cited the growth in high-rise building as a prime consideration in their decisions to leave.
More vintage picture postcards from San Francisco in the ’70s
Oakland, BART, the freeway, Bay Bridge and San Francisco skyline
The old Embarcadero Hyatt hotel in downtown SF
A beautiful 1970s city view
Lombard Street — “Crookedest Street in the World” — is seen here in the center foreground
Old San Francisco cable car: Powell & Mason Streets
Video: The real streets of San Francisco in the ’70s (circa 1974)
A 1970s drive through the gritty San Francisco streets (Fillmore, SOMA)
Vintage An aerial view of downtown San Francisco (1976)
Trane Air Conditioning – What TRACE will do for energy cost savings downtown… The Trane comfort corps brings home to you. TRACE (our acronym for Trane Air Conditioning Economics) is a unique computerized analysis program…
San Francisco street scenes from the seventies (video)
We left our hearts in San Francisco! …and a case of Canadian Club. (1980)
San Francisco! What better place to hide a case of golden Canadian Club than the city where millions came to seek gold in the Gold Rush of 1849?
So, we boarded a cable car on our way to hide a case of the world’s finest-tasting whisky in America’s most beautiful city. Do you know San Francisco well enough to find the CC?
A BART ride, a street with a past. Start at BART’s last city stop, and take a 30-cent ride. Change to another mode of transit, and ride until you can transfer again. Do so. and head for the farthest terminus, but debark at the first right-angle. Stroll a nearby street till it suggests a profession. Then head back toward your latter mode of transportation one block closer to your former. Where idlers gather, note who stays longest.
Find a way out of town but stay in. Now head straight to some rails and follow them as far as necessary to meet a way named for an important Gold Rush figure. Let it lead you to a way out of the city, but don’t leave. (If you’ve made it this far, don’t think things are looking up.) Now return to the last route you were directed to. Somewhere along it we hid our Canadian Club. Things you’ve seen should tell you where.
Tell the boss, “CC, please.” When you reach it, tell the man in charge “CC please.” You’ll receive a case of Canadian Club, the world’s finest-tasting whisky…
The 1970’s were the last decade that San Francisco would be affordable to live in as it would ever get. The period between 1945 and 1980 was an era of the so-called “White Flight,” when White couples and families left the cities to start new lives in the suburbs – creating a population “vacuum.” This outflow reversed itself beginning in the 1980’s.
No not “ white flight “. That’s when regulation started cracking down on inlaw units and creative living areas like basement studios. Then genius policies like rent control followed. People left the city to buy larger homes in the burbs with newer infrastructure for raising the kids. San Francisco had a mess of old homes and many were called earthquake shakes. The victorian and Edwardian homes were old and small. Many families left for the new tracks being built in westlake In the seventies people did what they wanted. I laugh when i hear things like “white flight “ Native San Francisco residents didnt see color in people until every freak in the union moved there and destroyed a peace loving accepting community. Dividing it up and demanding special treatment. Sorry but thats true. Now the city is crap. I left after 55 years. What a shame.
Not really – when the New York Giants moved to San Francisco in 1958, player Willie Mays was denied a mortgage in the city because of racial covenants that were in place.